Bitcoin 2.0: One World, One Cryptocurrency is ‘Unrealistic and Counterproductive’

By Clay Michael Gillespie Jan 5, 2015 3:28 PM EDT

NEW YORK (InsideBitcoins) — Developers working on bitcoin 2.0 initiatives are starting to feel pressure from all sides. As they begin to splinter away from each other to focus on their own projects, they also start to compete with one another.

In a recent blog post, Ethereum developer Vitalk Buterin talked about the increasing fragmentation the cryptocurrency space sees, specifically regarding blockchain-based projects.

“Not only is fragmentation not all that bad, but rather it’s inevitable, and arguably the only way that this space can reasonably prosper.”

“What was earlier perhaps a more tightly-bound community centered around developing the common infrastructure of Bitcoin is now increasingly a collection of ‘silos,’ discrete projects all working on their own separate things,” Buterin wrote. He hinted at projects like BitShares, Blockstream, Truthcoin and Maidsafe, saying that they’re all no longer working on one idea.

For example, Counterparty recently took a stab at Ethereum by replicating their smart contract system into Counterparty’s platform. But even while Counterparty competes with Ethereum, Buterin doesn’t seem to mind. In fact, he wants all bitcoin 2.0 companies to continue competing.

“Not only is fragmentation not all that bad, but rather it’s inevitable, and arguably the only way that this space can reasonably prosper,” Buterin wrote.

Cooperation toward something bigger

bitcoin 2.0Bitcoin 2.0 itself is a complex concept that’s just recently come to life. Bitcoin was the foundation; the infrastructure that allowed for the blockchain to prosper. Over time, bitcoin became famous and attracted new minds and developers to learn the technology. For years now, people studied the complexities and found ways to utilize the blockchain in different ways; other than for financial gain.

Individual developers with an understanding of the sophisticated cryptography began to see the potential in the blockchain. They started developing layers on top of the blockchain, such as tokens and services.

Peter Kirby

Peter Kirby

Peter Kirby, the president of Factom, told Inside Bitcoins how these groups are all working to build something much larger than what people see today.

“The way we think about Factom is it’s just a data layer that sits on top of that bitcoin blockchain,” Kirby explained. “It lets you basically say ‘now I can start writing not just value transactions, like bitcoins; I can start writing data and ledgers and all sorts of non-financial transactions.’”

“These are tools, and smart people will pull together different tools to solve interesting problems.”

Projects like Storj allow people to use its distributed file storage system, keeping their documents safe while utilizing multi-signature technology. Ethereum enables distributed scripting, along with presences through their token “ether” and their Mist browser. These tools that developers are creating are layered on top of each other, rather than competing.

“You realize they’re not competing, they’re just building a really robust open-source, distributed system that lets us build much more interesting applications,” Kirby said. “The message here needs to be this: These are tools, and smart people will pull together different tools to solve interesting problems.”

Nick Lambert

Nick Lambert

Nick Lambert of MaidSafe sees the benefits of working on different tools separately.

“I very much agree with the notion that fragmentation is good and having creative minds all approach the same problem in a different way is very healthy for the crypto community,” Lambert told Inside Bitcoins. “Trying a number of different consensus models, for example, and measuring how effective they are for their chosen application is vital for ongoing innovation and evolution of ideas.”

What’s creating the divide?

Buterin seeks a stable cryptocurrency, but Daniel Larimer, the founder of BitShares, recently said that a stable currency was impossible, impractical and even undesirable.  While the two may vehemently disagree, their ongoing public debate explains why bitcoin 2.0 fragmentation has occurred in the first place.

“Why has fragmentation been happening, and why should we continue to let it happen? To the first question, and also simultaneously to the second, the answer is simple: we fragment because we disagree,” Buterin wrote.

 One world, one cryptocurrency

“One of the biggest challenges facing the industry is creating a platform for the leaders of these projects to come together and discuss their approaches so that they can learn from each other,” Lambert said. “This ties in with the point about having each project build modular components that function within other projects and I guess what we are really talking about here are establishing community programming standards, similar to a W3C (World Wide Web Consortium) for the crypto industry.”

Lambert believes the discussion could be advanced with the founding of an independent not for profit organization centered on research.

“Like Vitalik, I’m also not a ‘one currency to rule them all’ believer, it is too much to expect one coin or protocol to be the best at everything and most are designed with specific purposes in mind,” Lambert said. “We are currently at the dawn of decentralized consensus models and trying to get everyone to get behind one project is both unrealistic and counterproductive.”

  • IdPnSD

    “… the answer is simple: we fragment because we disagree,” – Naturally, because money is false. Money is not an object of nature, therefore it is false, free, and abundant at its source, which is the central bank. How can then people create consensus?

    Remove money; try to create money-less economy (MLE). MLE is the only system that is based on the laws of nature. After all, why do we need money? You give me money so that I can work for you. I need your money to buy my food and shelter. There is no other need for money. Why not then we all work free and government gives us food and shelter for free?

    MLE will remove poverty, unemployment, wars, pollution, migration etc. Only MLE can give us full democracy and any life style we want. Take a look at the MLE chapter in the free book at https://theoryofsouls.wordpress.com/ MLE can give us One World from day one.

  • Дмитрий Савельев

    GLOBAL PRIME Pre-2016 COINSPACE

    http://bit.ly/22HWbie

    now begin their prelaunch registration campaign and enabling marketing professionals to position themselves at the beginning of global expansion program with an incredible growth and income potential.

    We are the first network marketing company to offer intelligent cloud services. Our production of the cloud allows anyone the opportunity to start in cryptocurrency industry. With a dedicated team of dealers, contributing to the growth and success, it really is a unique opportunity, and there is no better time than now to get started! Our solution: for those who are new to the world as well as for cryptocurrencies cryptocurrency experts and large investors. Network Coinspace uses its purchasing strength, leverage and ability to offer programming are members of the legal opportunity to earn money by sharing profits and investing in mining companies. This is an opportunity to earn passive income from Coinspace.

    We offer you:

    the opportunity to start their own support us. It’s just, it’s just to tell the world about us and earn extra money easily and permanently. We provide you with personal individual program Money Maker. Direct payments on your prepaid debit card. . Cash rewards for new members, one-year contract, instant profits, with no electricity costs, no costs for installation of additional equipment, software costs and maintenance costs

    We are looking for:

    If you are a person with big dreams and would like to support others to achieve their big dreams, you are the one to be in our team, and you can start a useful plant to your dreams and goals today.

    We offer amazing benefits that have universal appeal to the masses of people seeking financial success and independence.

    It is time to take action !!!

    With our new cryptocurrency Scoin, our Cloud Mining Licenses and on probably the most sensational compensationplan around the world, you have the chance to create a huge profit from a binary commissions and get real company cars (binary Commission, does not comply with the award to the 3rd generation straight commission, company car S-coins as a loan for the rank, the incentive for the rank and programs for the company’s participation …

    http://bit.ly/22HWbie

    A Real Crypto Currency Opportunity

    Crypto Currency is the future of money! The adoption of this new global currency is happening right now and the market is growing exponentially.

    With CoinSpace you have the opportunity to get in now and earn Crypto Coins every day from our strategic mining efforts. We have combined network marketing with crypto currency mining to bring you an opportunity that is second to none.

    You can earn daily profits without ever sponsoring anyone… However, sponsor new members and your earning potential is huge. You will earn daily profits from all of the daily profits being earned by your entire team. You have to see it to believe it!

    Don’t wait… Do yourself a favor and jump in RIGHT NOW!!

    http://bit.ly/22HWbie

  • Дмитрий Савельев

    Take a FREE Look!
    http://bit.ly/1nRkF9P
    A Real Crypto Currency Opportunity

    Crypto Currency is the future of money! The adoption of this new global currency is happening right now and the market is growing exponentially.

    http://www.s-coinspace.com/biz.html

    With CoinSpace you have the opportunity to get in now and earn Crypto Coins every day from our strategic mining efforts. We have combined network marketing with crypto currency mining to bring you an opportunity that is second to none.

    You can earn daily profits without ever sponsoring anyone… However, sponsor new members and your earning potential is huge. You will earn daily profits from all of the daily profits being earned by your entire team. You have to see it to believe it!

    Don’t wait… Do yourself a favor and jump in RIGHT NOW!!
    http://bit.ly/1nRkF9P
    http://www.s-coinspace.com/biz.html

  • inpips

    yeah premined with a daily “transaction” volume of less than $800

  • Nemesis

    scam

  • tronspecial

    Trying to have one cryptocurrency is like trying to have one church with one pope. It doesn’t turn out well in the long run.

  • tronspecial

    A stable crypto currency exists. It’s called NuBits. http://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/nubits/

  • One vital point missed, MaidSafe is non blockchain, and the onlyrival *consensus mechanism* in the game. Yet to launch, we have to wait and see how disruptive it will be too all the blockchain based projects, but it could be BIG.

  • allseeinguy

    Once bitshares, maidsafe, ethereum and supernet are up and running ‘established’ there will be no looking back. Can’t wait to see what this year has in store.

  • Snyke

    While I agree that different Bitcoin 2.0 project should compete on a feature level, I think that competing about resources slows evolution down. If every project requires its own resource supported blockchain then each individual blockchain becomes weaker against attacks, like it happened a few times in the past.

    There needs to be a common blockchain, built by aggregating all the resources, that serves as a platform on which to build new innovative projects. Otherwise requiring every project to come up with the necessary resources to launch is a major roadblock and is wasteful with respect to resources.

    A possible solution is presented in http://arxiv.org/abs/1412.7935.

  • AlexVela

    Can’t find much about pebble, the smart watch?

  • Bonez0r

    What about SuperNET?

    “The blockchain has been called the ‘Internet of money.’ But what if there were an ‘Internet of blockchains?’

    There is.”

    http://cointelegraph.com/news/113229/supernet-super-competition-for-fiat
    (sorry for linking to a competing site, but it’s a good article, very positive :))

  • There is no such thing as the Internet of Money (“Bitcoin”) only Internet monies (every coin). The same thing holds for smart contract systems, prediction markets and so on. Therefore of course there will be competition and fragmentation. But remember, competition drives innovation and progress. For those interested in what Pebble is doing, please follow me and wait for announcements.

  • Clay Michael Gillespie

    From my conversations with Factom and Maidsafe, it seems like a lot of people do. I think they all realize their efforts are leading to one major technology shift, but that’s just speculation on my part. I’d be interested in talking with a bitcoin 2.0 company that doesn’t agree.

  • OneMillionGateways

    Agree with Vitalik.

Read more:
shutterstock_106981193.jpg
Console Games Shift to “Digital Only”, Payment Methods To Do The Same?

In recent years, we have seen a noticeable trend in the world of video games. Or to be more precise,...

Close