24hBTC$62,405.003.1%ETH$1,765.702.2%BNB$578.832.4%XRP$0.95571.9%SOL$72.951.9%TRX$0.31000.6%DeFi value locked$71.71B
iGaming desk

Fourth Circuit backs Maryland against Kalshi, deepening a circuit split over prediction markets

The 2-1 ruling sets no majority precedent on whether Kalshi's contracts are CFTC-regulated swaps, and the split among federal appeals courts now heads toward the Supreme Court.

A federal appeals court ruled 2-1 on 17 November that Maryland may keep enforcing its gambling laws against Kalshi’s sports event contracts, affirming the district court.

Key takeaways

  • The Fourth Circuit’s one-line per curiam in No. 25-1892 reads in full: “The judgment of the district court is AFFIRMED.”
  • The three judges gave three different answers on whether the contracts are Commodity Exchange Act swaps, so the ruling sets no majority precedent on the core question.
  • The Third Circuit previously sided with Kalshi in New Jersey, while the Sixth and Ninth Circuits rejected its arguments, and a Supreme Court petition in that case is pending.

The US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit published the opinion in KalshiEX LLC v. John A. Ma, No. 25-1892, on 17 November 2026. The unsigned per curiam portion gives no reasoning at all: it reads, in full, “The judgment of the district court is AFFIRMED.”

The fight dates to 7 April 2025, when Maryland’s gambling regulators sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter that said its sports event contracts amounted to wagering conducted outside the state’s licensing system. Kalshi went to court two weeks later, arguing that the Commodity Exchange Act, the federal statute governing derivatives, takes precedence over state rules on sports betting. District Judge Adam B. Abelson denied Kalshi’s preliminary injunction on 1 August 2025, reasoning that Congress had not spoken with the clarity the preemption claim required and that the states kept their authority over gambling.

On appeal, the three-judge panel reached the same result by three different routes. Judge Roger L. Gregory declined to decide whether the contracts are swaps, the Commodity Exchange Act category that would place them under the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s exclusive jurisdiction. Even assuming they are, he wrote, federal law does not clearly displace Maryland’s authority to regulate sports gambling. “Until Congress and the CFTC are clear, I conclude that Maryland has concurrent authority under these facts,” he wrote.

Judge Stephanie D. Thacker went further, concluding the sports event contracts do not qualify as swaps at all because the outcome of a sporting event is not itself an event, and that Maryland officials can co-regulate them. Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented, arguing the contracts are swaps within the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction and that federal law occupies the field, leaving no room for state gambling laws.

That three-way split matters beyond Maryland because the federal appeals courts now disagree with each other. The Third Circuit sided with Kalshi in New Jersey’s Flaherty case, while the Sixth and Ninth Circuits rejected its arguments in cases from Ohio, Tennessee and Nevada. Kalshi’s petition asking the Supreme Court to hear Flaherty is pending, and the 17 November ruling gives it more weight: a court split of this kind is the classic trigger for Supreme Court review.

The dispute is also far from over. The Fourth Circuit affirmed only the denial of a preliminary injunction, so Maryland’s underlying enforcement action remains before the district court and Kalshi may still prevail on the merits. The CFTC’s 2026 rulemaking proposals on event contract swaps are also pending.

The ruling came amid a wider wave of state action against prediction market operators, including the CFTC’s own lawsuit against state enforcement in Utah. On 16 November, a federal judge consolidated the CFTC’s lawsuit with Louisiana’s removed state suit into Polymarket’s federal complaint, and on 17 November Utah sued the companies behind sweepstakes casino Stake.us over alleged illegal gambling in the state since 2022. Kalshi separately dropped its own preemptive suit against Louisiana officials without prejudice.

For help with gambling-related harm, see this site’s responsible gambling resource.